Vicki Robin
Home Parent Page About PCDF Books American Experiment Living Economies Global Civil Society Documents Info Service Archive Other Resources Projects Archive The Great Turning YES! Magazine David C. Korten

The
People-Centered
Development
Forum

Seeking a just, inclusive, and sustainable world that works for all

Home
Parent Page
Tom Ambrogi
John Cavanagh
Richard Conlin
Lee Drutman
Rich Lang
J. MacDonagh
Raffi
Vicki Robin

                ****
The Sun interviews David Korten September 2007

"Living Wealth"
YES! Fall 2007

****
Home
Parent Page

               ****
In Loving Memory
Donella H. Meadows (1941-2001)
The Global Citizen

Feedback and Critical Commentary on

"Renewing the American Experiment"
[HTML]  [PDF]

by David C. Korten

Vicki Robin, president, New Road Map Foundation

There are two dimensions I think about that are implied but not explicit in your essay...

1. conservatives might not consider America an experiment - I think there is a structure to "our" story of delight in continuous learning and growth, that this is the nature of the life well lived whereas the structure in the conservative story is of a universe delivered whole by the divine with embedded moral laws and the life well lived is a life that adheres to the highest moral standards required by the Creator.  It's a big difference - dynamism versus order.  These of course are the two forces of the universe.

2. Both stories talk about freedom yet see it so differently!  Actually, it's a question of what do you control and what do you allow to organize itself.  It would be interesting to ask a set of freedom questions - what must we control as a society in order to have the maximum freedom for us as citizens? We all share a love of expansiveness, we all share a willingness to limit that which will harm what we hold dear, but where any one of us would place those fences is very different.

Posted January 26, 2004